Skip to main content

Let Yourself be Called Out for Racism- the Trouble with Tone Policing

 Something happened after George Floyd that caused a shift in response to racial injustices across the country.  More people were paying attention than ever before.  For some black people, it caused an awakening of their voices like never before.  This has sometimes led to some being more vocal in opposition to their friends, like me and you, and our ignorant or even combative comments and ideas.  

You see, sometimes, even though we are well-intended and think we are beyond needing correction about racism, we actually DO need correction.  It is a gift when our black friends or friends of color correct us because they don't have to.  They could just let us be ignorant and subconsciously racist or biased and just carry on- KNOWING that you have some deep seated ideas down in there.  Sometimes this results in their taking a step back from you and perhaps spending less time having real conversations.  Their trust may be broken and they don't feel comfortable telling you why.  If this happens to us, this is a problem! This is how friendships are lost.  

Why don't they feel comfortable confronting us? Because they think we can't handle it and it isn't worth their time.  It takes  A LOT for people of color to want to talk about their painful racist experiences and it takes a lot especially for them to want to talk about it on a personal level when they think you or I won't take the criticism well.  It makes them feel vulnerable and unless they believe that you WILL in fact take it and change with the criticism, they will most likely just revert to being more superficial friends.  

Black people get toned policed often.  This means that when we are told we are wrong by them we only want to be taught these things on our own terms.  We want them to tell us these things in a certain way using certain words with certain mannerisms and gestures.  Basically, we want them to tell us in as nice as way possible so we don't feel uncomfortable.  We forget then that we initially made THEM feel uncomfortable and hurt but that doesn't seem to matter.  We again are only caring about OUR feelings and pain.  If you want to be a true friend to a person of color and continue with the same depth of relationship as before and even deepen that friendship in the future- you HAVE TO TAKE CORRECTION IN ANYWAY IT IS GIVEN.  That may be hard.  That may be super uncomfortable. You may feel bad, guilty, or even like a bad person.  But if you listen to the criticism- you'll learn something.  If you act on it, you'll become better.  And they'll accept you back and accept you more because you aren't afraid to hear hard things and change.  

This whole movement is about change- changing hearts and changing our society.  We can't do that unless we are uncomfortable.  If a muscle is to be strengthened and changed, it must first be torn down THEN we can build it back up.  

The following video is great about describing more on this subject of Tone Policing.  



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Appreciation and Criticism of DiAngelo's White Fragility

The basis of this blog comes in part from the book "White Fragility" written by Robin DiAngelo in 2018.  I had never heard of this book until recently when I suggested to friends on Facebook that we make a list of resources to learn about race relations and Black history and a friend mentioned she was reading this book.  The book gives a basic understanding of terms we use today when talking about race: Racism, discrimination, white privilege, and white supremacy to name a few.  DiAngelo goes through ways in which white people may say and do things that are racist due to white supremacy being so far ingrained in our society that we don't even realize we are living in it.  When I started reading it I felt myself nodding and saying "that's true" throughout most of the book.  I have had almost every conversation she mentions in the book-verbatim.  I have spoken to friends of color and they have discussed that these things indeed DO bring them frustration and c...

The Reason Behind the Name "Invulnerable Fragility"

 "Invulnerable Fragility" is an oxymoron, I know.  When I tried to name this blog I went through several names.  The first was "Get a Clue; Have a Heart" and I debated about making it a Facebook page rather than a blog and involving my husband.  As I thought it about, though, it didn't quite feel right.  So I went back to the drawing board and asked myself a series of questions.  Why am I doing this? What is the reason that I want to blog in the first place? Who is my audience? Answering these questions helped me to find a more defined path.  Several months ago, maybe even last year, my supervisor at work asked me and a co-worker to watch Brene Brown's Ted Talk on Vulnerability .  He said it had changed his life and felt we would benefit and he wanted us to discuss.  I started watching it casually from the link in the text he sent me and very quickly realized it was deeper than I thought it would be.  I needed to watch it more intently a...

Black History Month

Copied from my Facebook account:  February is the month that we can count on learning about and hearing about more Black stories than any other part of the year because our education curriculum has omitted it. This video does a great job explaining this. I am also of the opinion that we shouldn't have a Black History Month however, until we get a sufficient replacement, that's what we have. So throughout this month, I plan to post videos and articles to show more of Black history than Slavery and Martin Luther King and the usual people and events we hear about. Any time this effort has been given traction it gets slammed down. I hope moving forward in 2021 we can finally rewrite the history curriculum to include people of color to show their contributions and struggles because it makes up this messy yet beautiful tapestry of American History and deserves to be recognized. YOUTUBE.COM The True History Of Black History Month Below is a brief but very informative discussion o...